Back Pain: Why It’s Often Misdiagnosed as Slip Disc – And What’s Actually Going On

Back pain is one of the most common reasons people visit doctors, physiotherapists, and even emergency rooms. Almost everyone has heard someone say, “I think I have a slip disc,” even before getting a scan.

But here’s the surprising truth:

👉 Most back pain is not due to a slip disc.

👉 In more than 85–90% of cases, it comes from simple musculoskeletal causes—tight muscles, weak core, poor posture, facet joint strain, ligament irritation, or movement dysfunction.

Let’s break it down in simple words so you can understand your back better, feel more confident, and avoid unnecessary fear.

Why Do People Immediately Think It’s a Slip Disc?

Because the symptoms can feel scary:

Sharp pain

Pain going down the leg

Difficulty bending

Feeling stuck or stiff

But here’s the catch…

💡 Even muscle spasm can mimic slip disc pain.

Example:

Imagine you bend forward to lift a bucket. Suddenly your back “locks.”

You freeze.

You can’t straighten up.

You feel pain down your thigh.

Most people think: “Disc is out!”

But 9 times out of 10, it’s actually:

A protective muscle spasm

A facet joint lock

A strained ligament

Glute or piriformis tightness

Core muscle fatigue

These are painful, but NOT dangerous.

What Does Research Say?

1. Most back pain is “non-specific”

Studies show that 90–95% of back pain has no serious structural cause.

This means it does not come from:

❌ Slip disc

❌ Nerve root compression

❌ Fracture

❌ Tumor

Instead, it comes from muscles, joints, discs (mild degeneration), or movement issues.

2. MRI findings don’t always match symptoms

This is the biggest shock for most people.

Research shows:

52% of people with NO pain have bulging discs on MRI.

38% have degenerative discs.

27% have disc protrusions.

They are walking, working, travelling—and totally pain free!

This proves:

👉 A slip disc on MRI does NOT always mean it’s causing the pain.

How Muscular Problems Mimic Slip Disc Pain

1. Tight Hamstrings → Pain While Bending

A patient thinks the disc is “slipping” when bending forward, but actually the hamstrings are pulling the pelvis backward and overloading the back.

2. Glute Weakness → Radiating Leg Pain

If your glutes don’t support your hip, the lower back takes extra stress, irritating nearby soft tissues.

Radiating pain ≠ always nerve compression.

3. Quadratus Lumborum Trigger Points → Side Pain

QL muscle spasms cause:

Sharp lower-back pain

Difficulty turning in bed

Pain with coughing

It feels exactly like disc pain.

4. Core Fatigue → Back Strain

Long sitting makes the core switch off.

The back muscles then overwork and go into spasm.

Example:

A 30-year-old IT worker feels acute pain after 8–10 hours of laptop work.

He fears disc herniation.

Actually, it’s muscle fatigue and stiffness.

A Real Patient Story (Simplified)

A 42-year-old man came to the clinic with severe back pain radiating to his left leg.

He had difficulty sitting and getting up, and the pain increased after driving.

He had already done an MRI which showed L4–L5 disc bulge.

He was told he needed surgery.

But on assessment:

Straight leg raise was normal

No numbness

No weakness

Piriformis muscle was tight

Facet joints were tender

Diagnosis: Piriformis syndrome + movement dysfunction

Treatment: Physiotherapy

Recovery: 90% better in 2 weeks

MRI showed a disc bulge, but that was not the cause!

Then When Is Slip Disc the Real Problem?

True disc-related nerve compression usually causes:

✔ Numbness or tingling

✔ Loss of muscle strength

✔ Sharp electric pain below the knee

✔ Pain worsens while coughing/sneezing

✔ Foot drop (rare)

If these symptoms appear, an MRI and neurologist evaluation is needed.

How to Avoid Misdiagnosis

✔ Get a physical examination by a physiotherapist

Movement tests tell more than an MRI.

✔ Don’t rely only on MRI for diagnosis

It shows age-related changes, not always pain.

✔ Understand the source

Most pain comes from:

Poor posture

Weak core

Tight hips

Lack of mobility

Sedentary lifestyle

Sudden heavy activity

Stress and sleep issues

✔ Choose conservative treatment first

Research recommends physiotherapy as first-line treatment for most back pains.

Take-Home Message

Slip disc is real, but overdiagnosed.

MRI findings often create fear, even when the disc is not the cause.

Your pain is most likely from muscles, joints or posture.

Physiotherapy, movement correction, strengthening and lifestyle changes help in majority of cases.

With proper assessment, you can recover safely—without panic, fear, or unnecessary procedures.

Bibliography

Brinjikji W, et al. “MRI Findings of Disc Degeneration Are Common in Asymptomatic Individuals.” American Journal of Neuroradiology, 2015.

Maher C, Underwood M, Buchbinder R. “Non-specific low back pain.” The Lancet, 2017.

Chou R, et al. “Diagnosis and treatment of low back pain: a joint guideline.” Annals of Internal Medicine, 2007.

Foster NE, et al. “Prevention and treatment of low back pain.” The Lancet, 2018.

Deyo RA, Mirza SK. “The case for restraint in spinal imaging.” BMJ, 2015.

Van Tulder M, et al. "Musculoskeletal disorders and disability." Best Practice & Research Clinical Rheumatology, 2002

Physiotherapist in Guwahati, Physio in Guwahati, Best physio in Guwahati, Physio